As Shinigami Eyes does not have a legal basis for the processing of personal data, the Data Protection Authority has issued a ban on the use of the browser extension in Norway.
“This case is a matter of principle. Subjective assessments and tagging of identifiable individuals are threats to the free exchange of ideas on the internet. The person who is tagged is not notified and is not given the opportunity to object,” says then acting Director Janne Stang Dahl.
The Data Protection Authority received several complaints about the browser extension Shinigami Eyes (in Norwegian), which is available for Chrome and Firefox. The purpose of the browser extension is to identify and tag individuals on the internet and in social media, indicating to users of the browser extension whether the tagged individual is pro- or anti-trans.
Negative impact on the public discourse
The Data Protection Authority has considered whether use of the extension could be based on a balance of interests as its legal basis. We have concluded that Shinigami Eyes does not have a legal basis for the processing of personal data.
The Data Protection Authority has previously given notice that we would issue a decision against the browser extension, and we have maintained our previous assessments in this decision.
“Data protection exists to preserve a space where it is possible to express oneself. Evaluation of the quality of the expression should not be dependent on unknown tags following the individual across the entire internet,” says then acting Director Janne Stang Dahl.
Mozilla and Google informed of final decision
Despite repeated attempts, the Data Protection Authority was unable to establish contact with the developer of the extension in its evaluation of the complaint.
The Data Protection Authority will communicate its decision to Google and Mozilla, which make the extension available on their platforms.